BattleAxe First Read: Chapter Nine: Leavetakings at Dawn
Saturday, 16 December 2023 22:17![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
Chapter Four and Five | Table of Contents | Chapter Ten
NRSG: Welcome back to BattleAxe, everyone! Scales told me I did not have to do chapters 6, 7, 8, so here I am for chapter 9. To give a quick recap of what happened in-between:
1) There was a war council, where we learned that Gorkenfort was ravaged, “Rivkah’s body” was stolen, Magariz was severely wounded, and all but two of the brothers of the brotherhood died. The creatures are described like this:
“Large creatures, as large as the wraiths but far more substantial. Taller than a man, but man-shaped. They appeared to be made of old bones held together by yellowish ice; with very little actual flesh. Each had a skull of a strange tusked beast for a head, their eyes silvery orbs, beaks instead of mouths. Leathery wings tipped with talons. Frightening creatures. Huge raking claws for hands. And odd bits of white fur stuck over their bodies.”
2) Borneheld attacks Axis because the latter whispered “It’s all right” without knowing what was going on. Axis then says: “At least Rivkah loved and respected my father enough not to betray him. […] Would that your father had received such love and respect from our mother.” After this, Duke Roland tells them both off, and also smacks Borneheld in the face.
3) Earl Jorge tells everyone off for not focussing on Magariz, and we are totally supposed to dislike Borneheld and Priam.
4) Everyone puts together a plan: Borneheld’s soldiers will be sent via sea to Gorkenfort, while Axis and his Axe-Wielders will first go to the keep in the “Silent Woman Woods” (the last remaining forest in Achar), then to Smyrton, and then to Gorkenfort. Once there, Axis is to surrender control of the Axe-Wielders to Borneheld.
5) Axis is furious with Jayme for suggesting this, and confronts him over it. Jayme refuses to back down, saying that Achar needs to be united against the threat, and that he “[does] not want to sacrifice Achar to save [Axis’s] cursed pride”.
6) Axis finally accepts. We are told that the brother in charge of the keep is called “Ogden”, and that Gilbert will go along with Axis. Axis counts up travel times and somehow adds an entire month, which no one notices.
7) When Moryson and Jayme are alone, we learn that the body in Gorkenfort was not actually Rivkah’s body, which we could have guessed from the prologue already. There is also a white cat with “bright blue eyes” who is very partial to Axis, and who will be plot-relevant later on.
8) Faraday gets betrothed to Borneheld on the 11th of September. She is uncertain about this, as he is “so large, so overbearing, and his manners [are] so gruff.” When we see him, he mostly looks uncertain about how to deal with Faraday, though. He gives her “a large ring of twisted dark gold with a massive round ruby”.
9) Faraday is also supposed to go along with Axis, and her final destination ought to be Earl Burdel’s household in Arcen (the capital of Arcness), as that is safer. Embeth will also go along.
By the way, I have decided to drop most of the counts, given that I have not done these chapters. I will only keep A Better Commando Name for the time being.
Well, those were chapters 6, 7, and 8. On to chapter 9, then!
Chapter Nine: Leavetakings at Dawn
We open on Axis walking about the palace courtyard “in the predawn darkness”, impatient to be moving and “irritated beyond measure that he [is] to be saddled with a group of women.” Again, why does Douglass think we would like Axis? Because he has more charm than Borneheld? For me, that certainly does not make up for what a misogynistic bastard he is. He says that the fact that Embeth goes along “[does] not diminish his displeasure one whit.”
Now he calls out for his lieutenant, who is called “Belial”. Ummm… From this link: “Belial is a Hebrew word "used to characterize the wicked or worthless".” So why in the world is Axis’ lieutenant named like that? I might see it if he is supposed to be the Traitor from the Prophecy, but I know that is not the case, so… I do not know.
A Better Commando Name: 19
Regardless, Belial appears, “a tall, well-built man with deeply set hazel eyes and a thick line of fine sandy hair over his tanned and beardless face.” He is wearing “a plain, grey woollen tunic over a white shirt and grey leather trousers”, which is the usual uniform of the Axe-Wielders. He is “some seven or eight years older than Axis” (so around 36-37), but he has never aspired to be BattleAxe, as he rather wants someone else to have ultimate responsibility and he serves happily under Axis.
Axis asks why everyone is not in formation, because it is later. Belial takes no offense “at [Axis’s] short temper”, as he is always “tense and irritable” before they move out. He patiently explains that this is the last cohort, and the others are all fit and ready to go. He uses a lot of fragments here, which does not fit the tone of the book at all.
Axis then asks where “these cursed women” are. Oh, stop talking, Axis! A voice from behind him says that “[t]hese cursed women” are “geared up, fed, watered, ah… packed, and ready to go.” Axis turns around, and sees it was Embeth. There is another reason for me to love her, it seems. Axis’s attention, however, is caught by “the huddle of female shapes behind her.” He thinks “Artor’s arse!”, and only just manages not to swear out loud.
He “curtly” tells he that he had not expected her to bring her “seamstresses, laundresses and chambermaids” with her (then maybe you could have asked her not to?), and he asks if she plans to teach his men “needlework”.
Embeth says that Merlion, Faraday, and herself brought their maids along, as they do not travel without attendants. At this, Axis snarls that he hopes they can ride, “because you’ll have to travel without them if they fall off their cursed horses crossing the first overflowing gutter they come to!” And then he disappears into the crowd. How has he not been reprimanded time and time again if this is how he behaves?
Belial gives them a sympathetic shrug, and then goes to fetch their horses. Embeth turns to the others, saying that she has heard Axis’s temper improves as the sun rises, and she hopes that is the case. Merlion mutters it is little wonder Priam does not receive him. She mentally wishes that Isend had given them a “more gracious escort” and one with a better parentage. Faraday “wriggle[s] in embarrassment” at those words (I do not know why, since he is very rude), and then abruptly giggles at the image of one of their maids falling into a gutter.
Merlion is horrified at this, but Embeth soon breaks into laughter, too. And I do like that they laugh about such a mean-spirited comment. Belial and several servants come with the horses, and everyone mounts up.
Faraday has just done so when she feels “a rough hand” touching her knee. It is Borneheld! The sun has just risen, and “a shaft of light” shines directly into his face as he looks at Faraday, in a scene that would work considerably better in a visual medium. He says he had to see her off (notably in the same paragraph as Faraday). She is too high for him to kiss her, so he awkwardly pats her leg instead.
She says she will count the days until she sees him again, “embarrassed by his attention in case Axis reappear[s].” She moves her leg slightly, hoping that Borneheld will remove his hand. He does stop patting her, but keeps his hand in place as he looks around the courtyard.
Axis then comes into view, “mounted on his dappled-grey stallion, Belaguez.” He rides over to Borneheld. Faraday is so mortified she wishes Artor would “reach down and snatch her from this life.” Well, I hope he does not, as she is one of the characters I actually like. She looks away. Cut to Axis’s POV, as he notes he recognises her from the banquet, and he knows who she is, as Isend spent the better part of an hour getting him as an escort.
Then comes the inevitable confrontation between the two:
- Axis says Bornheld’s name, and looks at his hand on Faraday’s knee. He feels “a moment’s sympathy” for her (not any longer than that, though; that would consume resources.)
- Borneheld sneers, and tells Axis not to lose too many of his Axe-Wielders.
- Axis tightens his hands on Belaguez’s reins, “causing the stallion to half rear.” (Because he does not care who he may hurt during his rivalry with Borneheld.) He says that if Borneheld cannot drag away from his coming marriage, he doubts Borneheld will “survive long enough to lead even [his] horse to water.”
- Borneheld “pat[s] [Faraday] patronisingly on the arm” (so why could she not lean down enough for him to kiss her earlier?). He “speaks without thinking, wanting only to irritate Axis.” And that is different from what Axis just did why? Do not think I do not see your double standards, Douglass.
- Borneheld says that Isend gave him “the reins to the finest mare in the stable”, and that Axis could never hope to “own anything this well-bred”. He laughs at his own joke and pats Faraday’s leg again. And why does the misogyny from Axis get a pass, Douglass? And no, the answer cannot be “because it is Axis”.
Faraday gets angry at this remark, so she startles her horse, which causes Borneheld to lose his footing. He “wave[s] his arms and stumble[s] alarmingly, almost falling to his knees on the slippery cobbles”. She quickly covers up for this by calling out his name anxiously. Borneheld regains his balance, and assumes she just momentarily lost control.
She “splay[s] her hands in a display of helplessness” and he smiles to reassure her, saying that he will teach her to ride properly when they are married. How evil! Axis has noticed this and says that “[t]he girl has spirit”. He says that maybe Faraday could “teach [him his] dance steps”, because the way he just moved was not impressive. Oh, how very wise and mature Axis is.
Borneheld wants to give a snappy retort, but he can only come up with telling Axis not to take too long. He pats Faraday for the last time, and then goes back into the palace. Faraday is cheered by Axis’s remark, but she shakes her head at what she just did. She wonders at “the antagonism between the two brothers.”
Jayme comes out, and Axis salutes him. Jayme tells him to ride well and fast, to get answers, and to remember his promise. Axis nods, and we are told that the tension between them has not cleared yet. He edges Belaguez away from Jayme.
Jayme gives Axis his blessing, and then Axis turns Belaguez around and addresses the Axe-Wielders. He asks if they are ready, and they respond they are read and “follow [his] voice”. He then tells them to ride, and some 5000 people ride out of Carlon, scaring the eagles and hawks on the city walls. End chapter.
In the end, this chapter is rather useless. We do not exactly need to see everyone getting ready to prepare each other, and the only reason I can think of for this to be here is to compare Axis and Borneheld again. And that comparison certainly makes Borneheld seem like the better brother, no matter what Douglass meant. If one of them is irritated by “being saddled with a group of women”, and the other does not show this, I am quite certain who I favour.
Regardless, it seems like the plot is leaving Carlon at least, so that might be something to look out for.
(no subject)
Sunday, 17 December 2023 10:18 (UTC)Ah, this must be why he has a crippled leg when he appears later on. I missed that little detail.
We never do find out who they put in that tomb if it wasn't her.
And yet All The Ladies Want Him for some godsforsaken reason. It's not as if he keeps his disgusting misogyny to himself, either; he treats every woman he meets like complete shit.
And here's Exhibit A!
Good question. He previously mouthed off to the KING, ffs. That sort of behaviour should have gotten him in serious trouble.
Indeed Belial is one of the only decent people in the whole trilogy, except for the part where he seduces a teenage girl.
He's always tense and irritable full stop.
Nope.
(no subject)
Sunday, 17 December 2023 12:59 (UTC)Ah, this must be why he has a crippled leg when he appears later on. I missed that little detail.
NRSG: Yes, this series's information management is not all too good.
We never do find out who they put in that tomb if it wasn't her.
Then why put it in, if it will not matter anyway...?
He's always tense and irritable full stop.
Oh, certainly.
(no subject)
Monday, 18 December 2023 02:45 (UTC)Indeed this is a depressingly rare example of something being established in advance rather than suddenly dropped in out of nowhere and explained after the fact.
(no subject)
Friday, 2 February 2024 00:41 (UTC)Have to say, it's very sweet of Borneheld to want to see his intended off. (I'm also curious to know how high up he had to reach to pat Faraday on the arm.)
I wonder if Axis is inspired by the umpty-thousand 'Manly Man' male romance leads out there - you know, the 'alpha males' who somehow attract the female lead despite having all the desirability of Vlad Masters and, if the covers are to be believed, ending at the neck.
(no subject)
Friday, 2 February 2024 08:30 (UTC)I suppose being upset at having to travel with a group of women is better then viewing them as a source of sex.
NRSG: Marginally better, but still.
Have to say, it's very sweet of Borneheld to want to see his intended off.
Certainly! And yet he is demonised for it, because why not.
(I'm also curious to know how high up he had to reach to pat Faraday on the arm.)
I think that Douglass did not envision this scene very well.
I wonder if Axis is inspired by the umpty-thousand 'Manly Man' male romance leads out there - you know, the 'alpha males' who somehow attract the female lead despite having all the desirability of Vlad Masters and, if the covers are to be believed, ending at the neck.
I certainly think so.
(no subject)
Friday, 16 February 2024 12:17 (UTC)So Axis is a sexist prick yet somehow we're supposed to cheer him on as the romantic lead? Because Bourneheld... exists? And doesn't like his disrespectful halfbrother who constantly causes trouble whenever he appears? And is awkward around Faraday but seems to at least like her? Cause honestly unless I'm given something solid to make me think Faraday wouldn't be safe with him...
Embeth continues to be the best character. In the kind of society Douglas is going out of her way to build, of COURSE noblewomen travel attended by maids and servants, because they need to be. Having a bunch of maids with you is, amongst other things, a really good way to counteract attempts to sully one's good name by the less pleasant type of people who use the idea of promiscuity as a weapon. Fuck's sake even MZB mostly got that one right. MZB.
Honestly Bourneheld is still coming across as in the right in this 'confrontation'. He was awkwardly trying to say goodbye to his fiancee and his prick of a half-brother started stirring shit in a way that suggests he does this every single time they're in the same room. At this point I'm not surprised Jayme is having him removed as AxeBoy, because his complete inability to not be an asshole to his own allies makes him a giant liability.
(Seriously I get SO MUCH awkward off Bourneheld interacting with Faraday that I'm actually kind of charmed. It's obvious that he's trying to be loving and supporting and even though he's not always getting the point across he's at least working at it. Whereas Axis only cares inasmuch as he's pissed off and has convenient female targets.)
(no subject)
Friday, 16 February 2024 21:24 (UTC)Wow, that is a lot of material to skip, and yet I'm not surprised you did looking at the summary. How is it possible to do so much in so few chapters and yet bored me completely just looking at the short version? Sheesh.
NRSG: Well, at least I did not lose the will to go onward. I think that might very well have happened if I had done those three.
So Axis is a sexist prick yet somehow we're supposed to cheer him on as the romantic lead? Because Bourneheld... exists? And doesn't like his disrespectful halfbrother who constantly causes trouble whenever he appears? And is awkward around Faraday but seems to at least like her? Cause honestly unless I'm given something solid to make me think Faraday wouldn't be safe with him...
Good summation! I am not seeing any of it, either.
In the kind of society Douglas is going out of her way to build, of COURSE noblewomen travel attended by maids and servants, because they need to be.
Exactly! It is such a ridiculous complaint!
At this point I'm not surprised Jayme is having him removed as AxeBoy, because his complete inability to not be an asshole to his own allies makes him a giant liability.
If only he would not be in command after this anymore...
(Seriously I get SO MUCH awkward off Bourneheld interacting with Faraday that I'm actually kind of charmed. It's obvious that he's trying to be loving and supporting and even though he's not always getting the point across he's at least working at it. Whereas Axis only cares inasmuch as he's pissed off and has convenient female targets.)
Indeed. A pity it will be quite some time before we see him again.
(no subject)
Thursday, 25 April 2024 03:13 (UTC)Borneheld and Axis deserve each other.
*there might be exceptions, e.g. you briefly brush or hold her leg while helping her climb onto a horse or other such inoccuous actions. This is not the case here.
(no subject)
Thursday, 25 April 2024 06:32 (UTC)NRSG: That is certainly fair. I stll think Borneheld comes across as a little better here, if only because I have constantly seen how awful Axis can be. In short, I think that I need more context to come to a reasoned conclusion about this.
(no subject)
Saturday, 27 April 2024 19:13 (UTC)(no subject)
Saturday, 27 April 2024 19:16 (UTC)NRSG: That they do... I am interested to see what will happen when they discover that Rivkah is indeed alive. I somehow doubt that Borneheld will get a touching reunion.
(no subject)
Tuesday, 30 April 2024 16:57 (UTC)(Something that also somewhat bugged me in Aquaman, when Arthur's mother met his brother after being missing and presumedly dead. It was kind of cold.)
(no subject)
Tuesday, 28 May 2024 13:00 (UTC)May I ask, why did we skip three chapters? It sounds like more actually happened in them than any of the previous ones. ...not that that's saying much, given how the plot of this book seems determined to crawl around slower than a herd of snails stampeding through molasses in winter.
-
Again, credit where credit is due. The author may have awful story-writing skills when it comes to the technical aspects, but she does know how to make some really awesome monsters. These things sound horrific in the best way.
-
Uh...how is this some kind of scathing insult? Not only is Borneheld not responsible for his mother's actions, but don't they have the same mother? Axis is essentially insulting himself with this!
-
Still don't see why we're supposed to hate Priam. He seems like one of the most decent characters we've met so far.
-
Wait, what? How does someone just overlook approximately thirty days? Can these people not count? (I'm assuming that their months are about the equivalent of ours.)
-
SHOCK, SURPRISE, I TOTALLY DID NOT SEE THIS COMING! WHAT AN AMAZING TWIST!
-
I can't see this going wrong in any way, shape, or form.
-
Screw you, Axis. Ever think we readers might not be too thrilled to be saddled with you as our protagonist?
-
Why not? Needlework is a good skill to have. Not only can you mend your own clothes when they get ripped up, but you can also stitch up wounds in a pinch.
-
I don't know if it's possible to physically reach through a computer monitor to strangle a fictional character, but damned if I'm not prepared to give it a try!
-
So kiss her hand. Don't you know anything about chivalry?
-
Who cares if he does? Borneheld is your fiancé; you're allowed to talk to him.
-
Oh, you son of a bitch. I was defending you, and you stab me in the back like this?! Punch him, Faraday. Kick him right in the face.
-
Atta girl! He deserved that, and more.
-
Why? That was awesome! He just implied that you were no more than a horse for him to ride, a possession that he owns.
(no subject)
Wednesday, 29 May 2024 06:55 (UTC)May I ask, why did we skip three chapters? It sounds like more actually happened in them than any of the previous ones. ...not that that's saying much, given how the plot of this book seems determined to crawl around slower than a herd of snails stampeding through molasses in winter.
NRSG: Because Scales wanted to abandon this, and I did not. By the time they had changed their mind, they told me I could skip these three chapters. At the time, it seemed like a good idea, but by now I am very sure it was not at all, given the context you are missing.
As for action... they still are quite boring, I must say.
Again, credit where credit is due. The author may have awful story-writing skills when it comes to the technical aspects, but she does know how to make some really awesome monsters. These things sound horrific in the best way.
Yes, she is quite good at that!
Uh...how is this some kind of scathing insult? Not only is Borneheld not responsible for his mother's actions, but don't they have the same mother? Axis is essentially insulting himself with this!
Also, why does he act like it was so horrible that Rivkah betrayed Searlas when Searlas is supposed to be so very evil?
Still don't see why we're supposed to hate Priam. He seems like one of the most decent characters we've met so far.
Apparently because he dared to be severely affected by hearing that Rivkah's body was stolen.
Wait, what? How does someone just overlook approximately thirty days? Can these people not count? (I'm assuming that their months are about the equivalent of ours.)
Because Douglass cannot keep her timeline straight? There will soon be another point where she accidentally states the date wrong.
SHOCK, SURPRISE, I TOTALLY DID NOT SEE THIS COMING! WHAT AN AMAZING TWIST!
And it is put as a quite big revelation, too!
I can't see this going wrong in any way, shape, or form.
Oh, it will indeed.
Why not? Needlework is a good skill to have. Not only can you mend your own clothes when they get ripped up, but you can also stitch up wounds in a pinch.
Looking at where the SCSF is now... that would certainly have come in nicely.
I don't know if it's possible to physically reach through a computer monitor to strangle a fictional character, but damned if I'm not prepared to give it a try!
Do try!
So kiss her hand. Don't you know anything about chivalry?
That had actually not occurred to me...
Why? That was awesome! He just implied that you were no more than a horse for him to ride, a possession that he owns.
Because apparently Faraday needs to be belittled at every turn? Even when it directly undermines the supposedly feminist message of this book?